Rehab loan diligence: The operator comes first

A rehab loan is secured by a house that is not finished yet. Why diligence on a fix-and-flip note centers on the operator, and how a lender weighs the bet.

Brian Eastman

All articles

Wendell has held two private notes in his IRA for a few years. Both are mortgage notes on finished rentals, with borrowers who have paid on schedule for as long as his plan has owned them. When an operator named Marisol asks whether his plan would fund the purchase and renovation of a house she intends to fix and sell, Wendell is interested right away. The loan would run for months rather than years, and it would pay a higher rate than anything his plan holds now.

His instinct is to check the deal the way he checks every note: confirm what the property is worth, look at the borrower's payment history, and check that the loan-to-value ratio protects his plan. On hard money loans like this one, those checks come up short. There is no payment history, and the value the deal rests on is what the house will be worth once the work is done, a figure built from Marisol's own scope of work and budget. What actually secures the loan on the day it funds is the house as it sits today, half-gutted or about to be. That projected after-repair value only becomes real if she finishes, so the evidence that matters is evidence about the work, and most of it is evidence about Marisol.

Where the evidence comes from

Every note asks a lender to trust something. What changes from one kind of note to the next is what the evidence is and whether it exists yet.

Kind of note What the evidence is When it exists
Seasoned note on an income property Current value and payment history Before the plan funds
Loan against a borrower's own home Income, obligations, payment history Before the plan funds
Rehab loan to an operator Track record, budget, schedule Partly before, mostly after

On the first two, the lender's job is verification. The property is standing, the payments have been made or missed, and the work is confirming that what was described is true. A rehab loan turns that job from confirming the present into projecting the future. The only evidence that already exists is Marisol's record on past projects. Her budget and schedule are forecasts, and the after-repair value is a forecast built on top of them. So Wendell has to read the one thing he can verify, her history, as evidence for what he can't: whether this house gets finished on her numbers.

Judging the operator

A credit score tells Wendell whether Marisol pays her bills. Her track record on comparable work tells him whether she finishes, which is the thing this loan depends on.

So Wendell starts asking himself different questions. Has she finished projects like this one, in neighborhoods like this one, close to the budget and schedule she is projecting for this property? Who does the work, a crew she has used for years or contractors she is meeting for the first time? When he forms his own view of what the finished house will sell for, does it land near hers? A gap between the two numbers is not automatically a reason to walk away, but it tells him something about either the deal or how Marisol priced it.

And if the house doesn't sell at her price, what happens next? Operators who miss on the after-repair value sometimes decide to keep the property as a rental instead. If Marisol did, would she refinance with a bank once the work was done, or would she ask Wendell's plan to stay in as a longer-term note, closer to the ones he already holds?

Marisol has done several of these, but a first deal would not have ruled her out. A first-time operator makes expensive mistakes because renovation is genuinely hard, and a lender who funds one takes on part of that learning curve, a risk Wendell could weigh like any other.

Wendell is new to this side of lending himself. He has never read a rehab budget, so before he answers Marisol he asks a lender he knows, someone who has funded flips for years, to go through her numbers with him.

Once he is comfortable with Marisol, the next question is what the loan is actually tied to. Operators who run several projects at once sometimes ask a lender to fund their LLC directly rather than record a new lien against each house, because it is faster. A secured note against the house being renovated ties the plan's money to this project. An unsecured loan to her company ties it to her word, and private lending fraud turns up far more often in that second arrangement than in the first.

Releasing the money in stages

Wendell's existing notes funded once, at closing. A rehab loan usually funds the purchase at closing and then releases the renovation money in draws as each phase of work is completed, so the plan's money goes out as the work adds value to the house. Staged funding changes what Wendell is agreeing to. Before he commits, he and Marisol need to settle what counts as a finished phase, who confirms it, and how quickly a draw is paid once it is, because a slow release stalls her crew as surely as a blown budget. Because his IRA has checkbook control, he can pay a draw the same day the work is confirmed.

The question before he says yes

The higher rate that caught Wendell's eye is what a lender earns for funding a house that isn't finished yet. So the real decision is whether the value securing his plan's money is enough to justify betting on Marisol to get the job done.

He works through it a few ways. If she stalls halfway, what would the house sell for with the work done so far, and how does that compare with what his plan will have out by then? If she finishes but the market softens, or she keeps the place as a rental and has to refinance, is there still a cushion between the loan balance and what the house would bring?

If the answers leave room to spare, Wendell is being paid mostly for his time and attention. If the numbers only work when Marisol finishes on budget and sells at her price, he is being paid to trust her, and her track record is what he is really relying on. Plenty of good loans fall on either side of that line. Wendell just wants to know which side this one is on before he wires the money.

Share this article